Upper Crust Pizza

Best pizza in Marathon and I always go there when in Marathon. A small seating area and a challenge to find off of Route 1. I guess that is all.

Pizza was sooooo delicious! My husband and I have high standards when it comes to pizza and the deluxe pizza we had is our new favorite.

This place is absolutely amazing. The spaghetti with Bolognese and meatballs was out of this world and the homemade desserts and pizza are amazing Highly recommend

Great place to get great pizza. I also see a lot of ppl getting the pasta with garlic bread, one day I’ll have to try it too. I go as often as I can, can’t get enough of the Happy Unicorn (white sauce) it’s sooo good. I love this place.

The three of us shared a large salad and a medium deluxe pizza. The salad portion was generous enough. The pizza was delicious. It’s a thin crust that is very tasty and not soggy the way thin crust can be sometimes. We also had a slice of key lime pie that was very good with just the right amount of tartness.

Very basic if you are eating in, but we got takeout and pizza was very good! Place looks run down from outside but give it a try for quick and easy pizza!

I am local. Have ordered before. Today I ordered my usual " create your own" and when we went to pick it up we were told someone else picked it up. How, we were not late. Just poor service. Do they not pay attention to the name on the order???

We ordered a medium Supreme pizza. It is served on a thin crust, no tomato sauce that we could taste, and not that many toppings for the cost. We had a frozen pizza from Publix that was more tasty.

Excellent in all regards - we had a larger pizza ( meat lovers) and cheese bread All very good Great service Back anytime Thanks

What an amazing experience!!! The food was incredible and the owners are so special!! I can’t say enough great things!! You must give a try!!!

Great food. Owner operated.. Nice people and service..

Salad and pizza was good. Family run, good service.

I believe this has the best Key Lime Pie in Marathon Florida 😍

Best pizza in town

Pizza is good. Customer service terrible.

Pizza was good, friendly service. Open late during weekdays !

Stayed in marathon for the week...went back three times. You have a few great options for pizza on marathon, but I always seem to head back to this one.

Pepperoni pizza was good but we didn’t love the garlic bread. Would order pizza from here again.

Great Pizza! Some of the best pizza we have ever had. Very fresh tasting and the desserts are amazing. Highly recommend!!!

Delicious food, best prices for the quality in all of the Keys that I have been to so far! You MUST go here if you Love pizza. It brings it to a fine craft here, Seriously the first time I’ve EVER eaten pizza with a fork and knife. It was THAT nice. Also extremely clean with phenomenal customer service. Thank you and Joseph and I will be back for more soon!!

Great little restaurant with friendly staff and quick service. The pizza was fantastic!

Surprisingly very good pizza. Both my wife and I were happily impressed with the quality of the flavors from both of our respective orders. Small hiccup with miscommunication regarding some pizza toppings, but overall a great, pleasant, & tasty experience! Will definitely come again!

Pizza was excellent great crust and friendly service